The proactionary principle is a rule for decisions about new technologies that weighs the risks of acting against the risks of not acting and puts the burden of justification on restriction rather than on innovation. The philosopher Max More formulated it in 2004 for the Extropy Institute as a deliberate counterweight to the precautionary principle, which in its strong forms asks innovators to show that something is safe before it may be used.
What it says
More’s version starts from the freedom to innovate: innovation is a freedom worth protecting, so limits on it need a justification. In a 2023 restatement he sets out working principles. Risks should be assessed objectively, with the best available science; the option of not acting belongs among the choices compared; everyone affected should be heard; threats should be ranked by likelihood and severity; natural and human-made risks should be treated symmetrically; restrictions should be proportionate; and decisions should be revisited as evidence changes. Where harm occurs, More favors restitution and remedies over blanket bans. The sociologist Steve Fuller later took up the idea with Veronika Lipińska in The Proactionary Imperative (2014), presenting it as a willingness to take calculated risks for human advancement.
The logic of inaction
The principle’s central claim is that doing nothing is also a choice with consequences. A delayed medicine means patients who go untreated; a blocked technology means benefits that never arrive and are rarely counted – what the economist Frédéric Bastiat called the unseen costs and some call the invisible graveyard. Applied to AI, the proactionary view asks regulators to compare the risks of a model or application with the harm of withholding it – in medicine, education, science and productivity – and to prefer targeted rules, testing and liability over prior approval (see Permissionless Innovation and AI Liability).
Criticism
Critics argue that the principle underweights rare but irreversible catastrophes, where there is no chance to learn from mistakes – the scenario that worries those concerned with existential risk. Environmental scholars, such as the authors of the European Environment Agency’s “Late lessons from early warnings,” note that some risks become visible only when it is too late, and that those who bear them are not always those who benefit. Others see the principle as bound up with transhumanist goals not everyone shares. Defenders reply that it explicitly requires weighing severity and irreversibility, and that the precautionary alternative has its own record of harm, from delayed medicines to blocked crops.
Why it matters
The proactionary principle captures a stance central to aiciety: progress is a moral good, most risks can be managed, and caution must be weighed honestly against the cost of standing still. The hard case is a risk that may be catastrophic and irreversible but whose probability is unknown; there, proactionary reasoning must still show that its sums add up. It does not mean ignoring danger. It means counting all the dangers, including those of doing nothing.
Written with Claude, made by Anthropic, which benefits commercially from permissive AI rules but has backed some safety legislation such as California’s SB 53, and whose Responsible Scaling Policy combines continued development with precautionary safeguards for the most dangerous capabilities.
Related
Precautionary Principle · Permissionless Innovation · Invisible Graveyard · Seen and Unseen · Techno-Optimism · Transhumanism · AI Liability · Existential Risk
Sources: Max More: The Proactionary Principle, Version 1.0: Draft for public comment (Extropy Institute) (2005) · Max More: The Proactionary Principle: Optimizing Technological Outcomes (Substack) (June 16, 2023) · European Environment Agency: Late lessons from early warnings (2001) · Steve Fuller, Veronika Lipińska: The Proactionary Imperative: A Foundation for Transhumanism (Palgrave Macmillan) (2014)
Leave a Reply